It will indeed appear on the top of the list. The only condition is that your password need to be exact same which you used while creating the wallet. Different wallet with same Mnemonic phrase would result in different set of addresses
For further actions, you may consider blocking this person and/or reporting abuse
Also, does my wallet should appear on top of the wallets list as before or could be down the line and I need to find it from the list
It will indeed appear on the top of the list. The only condition is that your password need to be exact same which you used while creating the wallet. Different wallet with same Mnemonic phrase would result in different set of addresses